Can You Eat Mouldy Cheese?

In many ways, mould is cheese. But not all mould is created the same. In this article, we’ll go through the different types of mould, and how you can tell them apart. Read on to find out if you can eat mould cheese. 

BUY NOW: Express your love of cheese with The Cheese Wanker’s Mould Is OK 100% Organic Cotton Grocery Bag →

Mould is cheese

Mould can be scary if you’re not used to seeing it on food. But it can actually be an important part of cheesemaking. If you’ve ever wondered whether you can eat mouldy cheese, we’ve got all the answers to your questions below.

If you’ve eaten cheese even once in your life (I know you have, you wouldn’t be here otherwise), then you have eaten mould. Are soft cheeses your jam? Meet Penicillium candidum. Are you more of a blue cheese fiend, say hello to our little friend, Penicillium roqueforti

What moulds are safe to eat?

Fluffy mould on the surface of cheese
Bunny tail mould on cheese – Murray’s

Picture this. You bought yourself a little treat the last time you were at your local cheese shop. A round of your favourite triple cream soft cheese, Brillat-Savarin. Today is the day when you get to dig into it! You’ve been waiting for this moment since you brought it home. You go to the fridge and pull it out.

Oh no, there is a patch of fuzzy mouldy growth on top of the rind! What do you do? Do not freak out! Read on to find out why this mould is perfectly safe to eat. Moreover, mould can be desirable in cheese.

Mould in cheesemaking

External blue mould on soft white cheese
External blue mould – Cheese Atlas – Source

Mould is used for various reasons in the cheesemaking process. Some like Penicillium candidum and Geotrichum candidum add the beautiful white textures that we all love on the rind. Others like Penicillium roqueforti and Penicillium glaucum add the blue veins that we all go gaga over in blue cheeses. 

Cheese is a living organism

In summary, mould contributes significantly to the aroma, flavour and texture of the cheeses we love. Furthermore, think of both the mould and the cheese as living organisms.

When you keep cheese in your fridge, it breathes and lives and continues to grow. So does the good mould. So, it is not uncommon to find fluffy bunny tails growing on the surface of soft white mould cheeses. Or patches of blue on some hard cheeses. One great example of the latter is a gorgeous Cheddar from Wales called Hafod. 

What types of mould aren’t safe to eat?

Cheese with black mould on it
Aspergillus niger on cheese – Bon Appetit – Source

However, there are some moulds that can be dangerous. The most common one is Aspergillus niger, a.k.a the Black Mould. This fungus will have a severe negative impact on the food product it contaminates and releases toxins in the body that can be harmful. Having said that, it is very rarely found on cheese.

Moreover, some other moulds can be a bit like an iceberg. You will only see a flat patch of greyish-blue or green on the surface of the cheese. The rest will lie under the rind.

Can mouldy cheese be eaten?

Also, remember that your fridge may not be a controlled environment and you do not really know what moulds are present. Therefore, we need some rules. The safest approach is to avoid eating any questionable mould. What you do with the rest of the cheese will depend on its moisture content and texture.

Cheeses you should discard

Bright colourful mould growing on cream cheese
Colourful mould on cream cheese – Reddit – Source

If it is fresh cheese (e.g. Ricotta, Queso Fresco, Cream Cheese) or pasta filata (e.g. Mozzarella, Stracciatella, Bocconcini), the best thing is to discard all of it. Those cheeses are high in moisture and quite soft. Because of this, the mould will have very likely penetrated all the way through. 

Cheeses you can save

Orange mould on wheel of cheese
Mould growing on hard cheese – Cheese Atlas – Source

On a more positive note, if it is a semi-hard (e.g. Comté, Gruyère, Emmentaler) to hard cheese (e.g. Cheddar, Gouda, Parmigiano Reggiano), the mould will most probably be only on the surface and can be sliced off. The rest of the cheese should be absolutely fine to eat. 

One last piece of advice

Do not leave cheese long enough in your fridge for it to develop contamination! Buy what you will eat within a week. One exception to this rule is if you are buying a whole wheel of cheese with a natural rind. Those will actually get better with time as you allow them to reach their “Best Before Date”.  

BUY NOW: Express your love of cheese with The Cheese Wanker’s Mould Is OK 100% Organic Cotton Grocery Bag →

Curds of wisdom direct to your inbox

Connect with Jonah & Sabine on our socials

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top